What Can I do if My CO Workers' Comp Insurance Company Avoids Looking Into My Claim or Misleads Me?

Colorado attorney for injured workers wants you to know your legal options if an insurance company acts in bad faith

All of your first-party insurance policies like auto, home and life owe you a duty to act in good faith. This applies to Colorado workers' compensation claims, as well, as they have been interpreted to be similar to first-party insurance policies.

Therefore, Colorado workers' compensation insurance carriers are obligated to investigate your claim or pay you the benefits you are entitled to under Colorado workers' compensation laws. If they do not fulfill this obligation or mislead you – a.k.a. act in “bad faith” – you then have the grounds to seek both economic and non-economic damages through an insurance bad faith suit.

This is not to say you have grounds for a Colorado bad faith suit simply because the insurance company makes a decision you do not agree with. However, if they hold back from you any medical benefits, lost wages and permanent disability benefits you are indeed entitled to under the law, you can obtain representation from a workers' compensation attorney to force the insurance company to pay those benefits.

Also, if the insurance company procedurally mishandles a claim as outlined in Colorado workers' compensation statutes, they can be subject to penalties and sanctions in the workers' compensation case but not necessarily a bad faith suit.

What would I be seeking in a Colorado bad faith insurance suit?

A workers' compensation claim and/or suit only allows you to obtain the benefits outlined in Colorado workers' compensation statutes, not any additional economic or non-economic damages resulting from an insurance company's bad faith conduct.

Take for example a trucker injured on the job who was told by his company's occupational accident insurance company that he was not entitled to full workers' compensation benefits when the law said he was. The insurance company actually had a workers' compensation policy in place the whole time but was refusing to pay full benefits.

This bad faith conduct caused many problems for the injured trucker, forcing him to go into debt, sell valuable possessions and rely on family to simply stay afloat. Not to mention the mental anguish and stress of being unable to secure his lost wages and medical costs.

A situation like this qualifies for a bad faith suit – intentional misleading by an insurance company that results in economic hardship and adds heartache to an already stressful situation. In the end, this particular case ended with a settlement between the injured trucker, his employer and the workers' compensation insurance carrier.

Who would represent me in a Colorado bad faith insurance suit?

If you're working with a Colorado attorney for injured workers to obtain benefits you are entitled to and it is discovered that the insurance company is acting in bad faith, another attorney from either within or outside the firm who has not been involved in the workers' comp. case will need to come in and co-counsel the bad faith case. Rules of Professional Conduct in Colorado state that an attorney should not “act as an advocate at a trial” in a case where the attorney will be a “necessary witness”.

In all likelihood, your workers' compensation attorney will be your primary witness in a bad faith suit. Therefore, it is improper under professional conduct rules for him/her to fully represent you in both lawsuits.

Being injured on-the-job is a bad enough experience, made even worse if you have problems obtaining your benefits. You assume your employer and Colorado workers' compensation insurance carrier will act honestly but sometimes that isn't the case. Bad faith suits are one way to hold them responsible for their actions and compensate you for the additional trouble in resolving your situation.

Continue reading these related articles for more information…

Talk with Us Today – a Free, No-Risk Consultation

Discuss the details of your claim with a Colorado Workers' Compensation lawyer at The Babcock Firm today. No matter where you are in the state of Colorado, if your case falls within our practice area and we feel our representation can benefit you, an attorney will conduct an in-depth consultation at no charge. We are here to help you secure a successful outcome. Contact us today and learn more about how representation works.


While the Babcock Law Firm tirelessly works to obtain successful outcomes for its clients, prior positive outcomes are no guarantee of future success. Indicating prior positive results is in no way intended to guarantee future results.

Related Articles From our blog
Workers’ compensation claims denial COVID-19
COVID-19 is Changing Workers’ Compensation Laws, Says Mack Babcock to NBC News

As if contracting COVID-19 wasn’t bad enough, some essential workers […]

COVID-19 workers’ comp claims denial
Why Are COVID-19 Workers’ Comp Claims Denied More than Other Injuries?

Across the country, COVID-19 continues to spread. With this spread, […]

CO workers’ comp
Can Colorado Workers Get Workers’ Comp Benefits for COVID-19?

As the novel coronavirus began its spread across the world, […]

Client testimonials Read all reviews

5-star review image
Work Comp Case
Workers Compensation  |  Thornton
Retained following injuries in a motor vehicle accident while working. Verified benefits were paid appropriately and negotiated settlement.
"I am very pleased with The Babcock Law Firm and how they helped my case . They worked very ..."
DC, Verified Customer
5-star review image
The best law firm
Workers Compensation  |  Denver
Retained for representation after client fell at work and broke his ankle. Assisted client and his wife to understand the workers' compensation claim process and obtained a final settlement when he wanted to get out of the workers' compensation system.
"I got injured on the job and Stephanie helped me get my pay check on time, meds for ..."
Christian Ray, Verified Customer
5-star review image
A big thanks to everyone
Workers Compensation  |  Greeley
Represented truck driver following injury out of state. Reached settlement on two separate claims following extensive medical treatment.
"Without everyone's help I would have been left out in the cold. I would recommend this Law Firm 2..."
Heath, Verified Customer
Association Badges
Association Badges