Denver Workers' Compensation Lawyer: Mack Babcock

(303) 683-5033 FREE CONSULT 4600 S Ulster St.
Suite 800, Denver CO 80237
  • Our Firm
    • Our Mission
    • Injury Attorney Profiles
    • How Representation Works
  • Practice Areas
    • Workers’ Compensation / Work Injuries
    • Car Accidents
    • Truck Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Drunk Driving Accidents
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Injured Truckers and Cab Drivers
    • Slip and Falls (Premises Liability)
    • Insurance Disputes
    • Wrongful Death
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Resources
    • Legal Library
    • Workers’ Compensation Guide
    • Scholarships
  • Locations
  • Contact
Personal Injury Attorneys (Home) › Attorney Blog › General › Courtroom Rule #1 – Stop Talking When the Judge Agrees With You

Courtroom Rule #1 – Stop Talking When the Judge Agrees With You

October 27, 2009

As a Colorado personal injury attorney who has been around a while, I am well aware of proper courtroom etiquette. But while catching up on my Colorado legal news, I came across a story that can help me illustrate what I’m talking about.

Casually referred to as “Rule 1”, I remember hearing this principle constantly as a law student and young Colorado workers’ compensation attorney. When the judge or jury agrees with you, stop talking!

Last week, a woman was on trial in Washington State for vehicular assault where the other driver suffered a collapsed lung and three fractured ribs. She was visibly shaking and crying as the jury filed into the courtroom to deliver its verdict. The woman and her supporters were gleeful when the jury delivered a “not guilty” verdict.

This is where Rule 1 comes into play – the defendant and her attorney should have then sat quietly but for whatever reason, the defense attorney asked the court to “poll the jury”. Ordinarily, this is only done in the event of a guilty verdict as this is one last chance the defendant has to break free of the charges. Rarely does it work but when you’re talking about your life, you would want your defense attorney to try anything right?

But polling the jury after a not guilty verdict is unheard of…not guilty means the case is closed, the defense wins and everyone can now go home in peace.

Unfortunately for the defendant, the first juror polled said she did not agree with the verdict so the jury was sent back to deliberate further. When they returned, the defendant was convicted of the lowest count.

The woman’s attorney, as attorney Scott Greenfield put it, essentially “…snatched defeat from the jaws of victory”.

I know the defense attorney in this case must be kicking themselves right about now for forgetting this important rule at such an important time. I wanted to write about it in my Colorado workers’ compensation blog to not only remind me, but to be sure all of my potential clients and readers of this are well aware of it.

Related Resources

  • Why Are COVID-19 Workers’ Comp Claims Denied More than Other Injuries?
    Why Are COVID-19 Workers’ Comp Claims Denied More…
  • Mack Babcock Discusses Colorado HB 1089 On Work Comp Central
    Mack Babcock Discusses Colorado HB 1089 On Work Comp Central
  • Mack Babcock Discusses Current Workers’ Comp Trends at WCEA Seminar
    Mack Babcock Discusses Current Workers’ Comp Trends…

Filed Under: General Tagged With: legal tips

5-star review image
Great Law Firm
Workers Compensation  |  Littleton
Representation for your workers' compensation case to obtain benefits after termination of employment in addition to a final settlement.
2015-11-20
"I couldn't be more pleased with the Babcock Law Firm. Although, I was one of many of their ..."
Rory, Verified Customer
5-star review image
Stephanie and Jan
Workers Compensation  |  Littleton
Retained for representation following denial of workers' compensation claim. Obtained settlement and resolved health insurance lien on client's behalf.
2016-08-13
"Stephanie and Jan were awesome with keeping me up to date with my case. Phone calls and emails ..."
MG , Verified Customer
5-star review image
Work Comp Case
Workers Compensation  |  Thornton
Retained following injuries in a motor vehicle accident while working. Verified benefits were paid appropriately and negotiated settlement.
2017-01-21
"I am very pleased with The Babcock Law Firm and how they helped my case . They worked very ..."
DC, Verified Customer
Related Articles from our Knowledge Center
General Info
Considerations When Hiring a Personal Injury Lawyer

Colorado's top attorney of workers' comp, auto accident and personal injury cases recommends what factors you should consider before hiring an attorney to represent you.

3 Reasons to Hire a Personal Injury Attorney

Think you can obtain fair compensation for an injury without an attorney in Colorado? Think again...

Send a Demand Letter before Filing a Colorado Personal Injury Lawsuit

Writing a payment demand letter may keep you from having to go to court.


View All General Information Articles

Blog Categories

  • Auto Accidents
  • Community
  • DUI/DWAI
  • Firm News
  • General
  • Insurance Disputes
  • Personal Injury
  • Premises Liability
  • Preventing Injury
  • Product/Safety Recalls
  • Workers' Compensation
  • Wrongful Death

Personal Injury
Practice Areas

Car Accidents Truck Accidents Motorcycle Accidents Drunk Driving Accidents Pedestrian Accidents Workers' Comp / Work Injuries Injured Truckers / Cab Drivers Slip & Falls (Premises Liability) Insurance Disputes Wrongful Death

Resources

Blog Contact Us Legal Library Workers' Compensation Guide Firm News
Association Badges
Association Badges
(303) 683-5033
The Babcock Law Firm
Denver Workers' Compensation Lawyer and Personal Injury Attorney Mack Babcock
4600 S Ulster Street, Suite 800 Denver, CO 80237 United States

Personal injury
practice areas

  • Car Accidents
  • Truck Accidents
  • Motorcycle Accidents
  • Drunk Driving Accidents
  • Pedestrian Accidents
  • Workers' Comp / Work Injuries
  • Injured Truckers / Cab Drivers
  • Slip & Falls (Premises Liability)
  • Insurance Disputes
  • Wrongful Death

Resources

  • Blog
  • Legal Library
  • Workers' Compensation Guide
  • Firm News

Free eBooks

  • Colorado Workers' Comp Guide
  • Colorado Car Accident Guide

Our firm

  • Firm Mission
  • Attorney Profiles
  • Practice Areas
  • Contact
  • Knowledge Center

    Facebook    Twitter    Blog

More
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Disclaimer & Terms of Use
  • Local & Reviews
© The Babcock Law Firm. Colorado law firm for workers' compensation, car accidents & personal injury. Serving all of Colorado and the Denver metro area from our Denver law office law firm internet marketing by SEO Advantage®