Denver Workers' Compensation Lawyer: Mack Babcock

(303) 683-5033 FREE CONSULT 4600 S Ulster St.
Suite 800, Denver CO 80237
  • Our Firm
    • Our Mission
    • Injury Attorney Profiles
    • How Representation Works
  • Practice Areas
    • Workers’ Compensation / Work Injuries
    • Car Accidents
    • Truck Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Drunk Driving Accidents
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Injured Truckers and Cab Drivers
    • Slip and Falls (Premises Liability)
    • Insurance Disputes
    • Wrongful Death
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Resources
    • Legal Library
    • Workers’ Compensation Guide
    • Scholarships
  • Locations
  • Contact
Personal Injury Attorneys (Home) › Attorney Blog › Auto Accidents › Frivolous Lawsuits in Today’s Judicial System

Frivolous Lawsuits in Today’s Judicial System

January 4, 2013

Discussing the differences between frivolous and civil lawsuits

Based on what we see on the news, it seems like people are suing each other left and right for the most absurd reasons.

Examples include: (1) Robbers filing suit homeowners for injuries that occurred while they committed theft, (2) drinkers suing breweries for their hangover and (3) prison inmates asking the state for compensation while serving prison sentences—these are real-life examples of frivolous lawsuits that happen in our world today.

But not all of these seemingly ridiculous lawsuits are what they seem. In fact, the line between frivolous and civil lawsuits can be quite thin, so what exactly is the difference between a frivolous and civil lawsuit, and how can you make sure your personal injury case gets the attention in court it deserves?

What is a Frivolous Lawsuit?

By definition, a frivolous lawsuit is a claim “filed by a party or attorney who is aware they are without merit, because of a lack of supporting legal argument or factual basis for the claims.”

Frivolous lawsuits waste time, money, and judicial resources, and penalties can be enacted on parties guilty of committing frivolous claims. Additionally, these impractical cases make corporations nervous and can cause an increase in service prices to cover intensified legal risks.

In contrast, a legal claim of dispute between private parties—persons or organizations—is known as a personal injury or civil lawsuit. These cases submit a valid legal argument for the plaintiff, and uses facts and evidence to support their claim. Civil cases, like frivolous lawsuits, also generally seek monetary compensation.

Cases of Frivolous Lawsuits

Most courtrooms can spot the differences between a civil and frivolous lawsuit from a mile away, and they quickly dispel them before it becomes a serious case, but some frivolous cases brought to court do occasionally slip through the net.

For example, in 1992, the Norman family sued Honda for compensation of the death of their daughter Karen. The teenager drowned when she backed into Galveston Bay (Texas) while driving drunk and was unable to unbuckle her seatbelt, according to the passenger who made it out alive.

The court awarded the Norman family $65 million for Karen’s death, even though her blood alcohol level was nearly twice the legal limit. The case was quickly appealed and tossed out later on.

The McDonalds coffee case is another example of a frivolous lawsuit that’s frequently cited. Again in 1992, plaintiff Stella Liebeck filed a lawsuit against McDonalds for monetary compensation for second-degree burns she received when she spilled the 180-degree coffee on her lap. Even more astonishing was that she won, and won big—$2.7 million in damages.

As you may remember, McDonalds got the settlement reduced to $640,000, but what you may not know is that originally Liebeck only sought $20,000 in compensation—just enough to cover medical expenses. The coffee was 40 degrees hotter than a coffee machine at home would typically be.

The media portrayed Liebeck as a money-grubbing customer simply trying to siphon a large company’s wealth, but in fact she only asked for reimbursement for her injuries. The additional compensation was offered by McDonalds and ultimately demanded by the jurors, not Liebeck.

Whether the Norman vs. Honda or Liebeck vs. McDonalds cases were frivolous or not are debatable, but they certainly show us that many cases which appear frivolous at first may have some validity in court – it also shows that these cases aren’t so cut and dry most of the time.

Frivolous Lawsuits today

The reality is most civil lawsuits today are not frivolous.

Out of the hundreds of thousands of Americans that are injured by medical malpractice, less than 10% file lawsuits. From 1995-2005, personal injury lawsuits decreased by 21%, despite a growing population in 30 states. This data tells us that people are not rushing to make frivolous charges as is often portrayed in the media.

In addition, the judicial system has laws in place to ward off frivolous lawsuits. These laws allow a judge to dismiss a case deemed frivolous before the trial even takes place, and lawyers can be sanctioned for frivolous claims and even be charged with a felony.

Conclusion

Many lawyers argue that the “crises” of frivolous lawsuit in the American judicial system ended years ago, which is why a minor case in 1992, over two decades ago, is the only case that ever gets used as an example of frivolous lawsuits.

In short, sure some frivolous cases have slipped through the net in the past and wasted court resources, but despite first appearances, in today’s judicial system most cases are civil and need proper representation in court.

To ask if your personal injury claim qualifies as a civil case, contact our Denver personal injury law firm today for a free consultation.

Filed Under: Auto Accidents, General, Premises Liability, Product/Safety Recalls Tagged With: car accidents, frivolous lawsuits, help your lawyer help you, legal tips, truck accidents

5-star review image
Workers Compensation Case
Workers Compensation  |  Aurora
Retained following denial of claim obtaining a financial settlement including resolution of a Medicaid lien.
2016-11-18
"Everyone at The Babcock Law Firm is very professional, made sure you understood everything before moving on. If ..."
Kelly, Verified Customer
5-star review image
Babcock Law Firm LLC Review
Workers Compensation  |  Aurora
Have provided representation for concurrent workers' compensation cases involving two different insurance companies and injuries to his shoulder, knee and hip.
2015-12-26
"I'm writing this review on behalf of my husband. "Mack and Jan and Mack's staff have assisted ..."
Bob, Verified Customer
5-star review image
Review
Workers Compensation  |  Aurora
Retained following a Final Admission of Liability with 0% impairment. Negotiated settlement for injured worker.
2017-10-13
"Babcock Law firm settled my case in a very timely manner. The attorney I worked with and the ..."
Barb, Verified Customer
Related Articles from our Knowledge Center
General Info
Considerations When Hiring a Personal Injury Lawyer

Colorado's top attorney of workers' comp, auto accident and personal injury cases recommends what factors you should consider before hiring an attorney to represent you.

3 Reasons to Hire a Personal Injury Attorney

Think you can obtain fair compensation for an injury without an attorney in Colorado? Think again...

Send a Demand Letter before Filing a Colorado Personal Injury Lawsuit

Writing a payment demand letter may keep you from having to go to court.


View All General Information Articles
Related Articles From our Knowledge Center
Slip and Fall
A Store's Liability for Slip and Fall Accidents

Every year, thousands of people sustain injuries from a slip, trip or fall. These accidents can occur anywhere, but many take place at various retail, restaurants or...

Most Common Slip and Fall Injuries and Tips to Avoid Them

Colorado personal injury attorney Mack Babcock discusses some of the most common injuries that people sustain from slipping and falling, as well as what you can do to avoid them...

Slip and Falls (Premises Liability) Overview

Slip and fall accidents are responsible for many injuries in Colorado every year, leaving victims dealing with everything from broken bones to spinal or head injuries...

View All Slip and Fall Articles
Related Articles from our Knowledge Center
Food Poisoning
Top 10 Culprits of Food Poisoning

According to estimates by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, food poisoning affects 1 in 6 Americans annually. This means approximately 48 million people become ill due to contaminated food this year.

Food Poisoning and Product Liability Claims

The Babcock Law Firm legal team talk about what it takes to win a defective product lawsuit for injuries sustained from a foodborne illness

6 Common Questions about Food Poisoning and Personal Injury

Denver's Babcock Law Firm answers a few questions about causes of food poisoning, symptoms and steps to avoid getting sick


View All Food Poisoning Articles
Related Articles From our Knowledge Center
Car Accident
When an Accident Occurs
  • What You Need to Know about Bus Accidents
  • Car Accidents Overview
  • What to Do After a Car Accident
Filing a Claim & Obtaining Compensation
  • How Injured Passengers Can Receive Compensation After a Car Accident
  • Common Arguments Used by Auto Accident Defendants
  • Taxi Cab and Ridesharing Accidents: How You Could End Up with Little to No Compensation
Car Accident Info & Prevention
  • Head Injuries and Car Accidents
  • Don’t Drive Drowsy! Tips for Staying Awake Behind the Wheel
  • Parking Lots – A Magnet for Car Accidents
(PDF) Colorado Car Accident Guide
View All Car Accident Articles

Blog Categories

  • Auto Accidents
  • Community
  • DUI/DWAI
  • Firm News
  • General
  • Insurance Disputes
  • Personal Injury
  • Premises Liability
  • Preventing Injury
  • Product/Safety Recalls
  • Workers' Compensation
  • Wrongful Death

Personal Injury
Practice Areas

Car Accidents Truck Accidents Motorcycle Accidents Drunk Driving Accidents Pedestrian Accidents Workers' Comp / Work Injuries Injured Truckers / Cab Drivers Slip & Falls (Premises Liability) Insurance Disputes Wrongful Death

Resources

Blog Contact Us Legal Library Workers' Compensation Guide Firm News
Association Badges
Association Badges
(303) 683-5033
The Babcock Law Firm
Denver Workers' Compensation Lawyer and Personal Injury Attorney Mack Babcock
4600 S Ulster Street, Suite 800 Denver, CO 80237 United States

Personal injury
practice areas

  • Car Accidents
  • Truck Accidents
  • Motorcycle Accidents
  • Drunk Driving Accidents
  • Pedestrian Accidents
  • Workers' Comp / Work Injuries
  • Injured Truckers / Cab Drivers
  • Slip & Falls (Premises Liability)
  • Insurance Disputes
  • Wrongful Death

Resources

  • Blog
  • Legal Library
  • Workers' Compensation Guide
  • Firm News

Free eBooks

  • Colorado Workers' Comp Guide
  • Colorado Car Accident Guide

Our firm

  • Firm Mission
  • Attorney Profiles
  • Practice Areas
  • Contact
  • Knowledge Center

    Facebook    Twitter    Blog

More
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Disclaimer & Terms of Use
  • Local & Reviews
© The Babcock Law Firm. Colorado law firm for workers' compensation, car accidents & personal injury. Serving all of Colorado and the Denver metro area from our Denver law office law firm internet marketing by SEO Advantage®