Denver Workers' Compensation Lawyer: Mack Babcock

(303) 683-5033 FREE CONSULT 4600 S Ulster St.
Suite 800, Denver CO 80237
  • Our Firm
    • Our Mission
    • Injury Attorney Profiles
    • How Representation Works
  • Practice Areas
    • Workers’ Compensation / Work Injuries
    • Car Accidents
    • Truck Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Drunk Driving Accidents
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Injured Truckers and Cab Drivers
    • Slip and Falls (Premises Liability)
    • Insurance Disputes
    • Wrongful Death
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Resources
    • Legal Library
    • Workers’ Compensation Guide
    • Scholarships
  • Locations
  • Contact
Personal Injury Attorneys (Home) › Attorney Blog › Workers' Compensation › Colorado Supreme Court Issues Judgment on Woman’s PTD Benefits

Colorado Supreme Court Issues Judgment on Woman’s PTD Benefits

June 15, 2010

We don’t often delve into court cases on the Colorado workers’ compensation blog and knowledge center but a recent decision by the Colorado Supreme Court is an exceptional circumstance since it overturns a decision from a lower court.

This particular case involves a woman who was injured working in a restaurant way back in 1990 – over 20 years ago now.

Scales of JusticeTo cut to the chase, a judge declared her permanently and totally disabled as of October of 2002 and awarded PTD benefits to her on December 5, 2006. In 2007, she elected to take a lump sum of $26,202 as an advance on her PTD benefits. At the time, this amount represented the statutory maximum aggregate lump sum she could receive.

That year, the Colorado General Assembly increased this amount to $60,000 through an amendment to the Workers’ Compensation Act passed many decades ago. The Colorado workers’ compensation agency (the Division) issued a non-binding advisory interpreting this amendment to be applicable to all claims without regard to the date of injury. The advisory was to be effective once the Governor signed the bill, which he did in May of that year.

In October of ’07, the injured worker applied for an additional lump sum payment of $33,798. Her request was rejected by the Colorado Insurance Guaranty Association, the workers’ comp insurer for her employer. They argued that a prior court case (Eight Thousand West Corp v. Stewart) declared that an injured employee was only entitled to the max aggregate lump sum at the time of injury.

On 12/19/07, the Division rejected CIGA’s argument and ordered them to pay the injured worker the additional lump sum payment. They appealed to the Industrial Claims Appeals Office (ICAO) for a review of the agency’s order. On 5/2/2008, the ICAO reversed the Division’s order.

The injured employee appealed the ICAO decision and was glad to see their decision reversed by the court of appeals on grounds that the 2007 amendment was procedural in nature and “operates prospectively on requests for lump sum payments filed after its date of enactment.”

In the final step, her employer and workers’ comp insurer issued an appeal to the Colorado Supreme Court asking them to review ICAO’s decision. They came back agreeing with the decision and ordered CIGA pay the woman the additional lump sum payment.

Reversing a lower court’s ruling rarely happens as most appeal cases to the Supreme Court are never even heard. As it stands now, the injured employee will receive the additional lump sum payment.

Reading this story should remind you – it usually takes many years to obtain your rightful workers’ compensation benefits. If you’re totally and permanently disabled, you want to ensure you receive the maximum amount the law entitles you to for your injuries.

If you’re experiencing problems obtaining benefits or simply want to know more, contact Colorado workers’ compensation attorneys at the Babcock Law Firm today.

Filed Under: Workers' Compensation Tagged With: Colorado workers' compensation laws, Colorado workers' compensation news, workers' comp insurance

5-star review image
Awesome Legal Representation
Workers Compensation  |  Colorado Springs
Retained for representation following denial of hip surgery for a work related injury. Following successful hip surgery and recovery, settled the case.
2016-08-13
"Stephanie and her team were so understanding and helpful during the time of my injury. I couldn't have ..."
Chris, Verified Customer
5-star review image
Dedicated; Amazing; Personal; Professional; Law Firm
Workers Compensation  |  Westminster
Retained for representation after injured worker put at maximum medical improvement with no impairment. Pursued a favorable Division Independent Medical Evaluation (DIME) and obtained a financial settlement for client.
2016-07-09
"Professional,dedicated & go above & beyond.Take the time to make sure you understand.Go over the routes you ..."
Beth, Verified Customer
5-star review image
Outstanding service
Workers Compensation  |  Denver
Obtained denied treatment for worker with injuries to his head, neck, shoulder, eye, and knee obtaining a settlement for him following his recovery from surgery.
2016-04-03
"Thank you to all at The Babcock Law Firm for all of your concern and professionalism. The experience ..."
Anonymous, Verified Customer
Related Articles from our Knowledge Center
Workers Compensation
When You're Injured
  • How to File a Work Injury Claim
  • Reporting a Work-Related Injury or Condition
  • Workers' Compensation Overview
Obtaining Treatment & Benefits
  • Workers’ Compensation for Law Enforcement Officers
  • Reasons Why Temporary Disability Benefits Can Be Terminated in Your Workers’ Compensation Case
  • Workers' Compensation Case Timeline
Work Injury Prevention, General Information
  • How Forced Arbitration Leaves Employees Helpless
  • Combustible Dust: An Explosive Work Hazard
  • 10 Common Workplace Injuries
View All Workers Comp Articles

Blog Categories

  • Auto Accidents
  • Community
  • DUI/DWAI
  • Firm News
  • General
  • Insurance Disputes
  • Personal Injury
  • Premises Liability
  • Preventing Injury
  • Product/Safety Recalls
  • Workers' Compensation
  • Wrongful Death

Personal Injury
Practice Areas

Car Accidents Truck Accidents Motorcycle Accidents Drunk Driving Accidents Pedestrian Accidents Workers' Comp / Work Injuries Injured Truckers / Cab Drivers Slip & Falls (Premises Liability) Insurance Disputes Wrongful Death

Resources

Blog Contact Us Legal Library Workers' Compensation Guide Firm News
Association Badges
Association Badges
(303) 683-5033
The Babcock Law Firm
Denver Workers' Compensation Lawyer and Personal Injury Attorney Mack Babcock
4600 S Ulster Street, Suite 800 Denver, CO 80237 United States

Personal injury
practice areas

  • Car Accidents
  • Truck Accidents
  • Motorcycle Accidents
  • Drunk Driving Accidents
  • Pedestrian Accidents
  • Workers' Comp / Work Injuries
  • Injured Truckers / Cab Drivers
  • Slip & Falls (Premises Liability)
  • Insurance Disputes
  • Wrongful Death

Resources

  • Blog
  • Legal Library
  • Workers' Compensation Guide
  • Firm News

Free eBooks

  • Colorado Workers' Comp Guide
  • Colorado Car Accident Guide

Our firm

  • Firm Mission
  • Attorney Profiles
  • Practice Areas
  • Contact
  • Knowledge Center

    Facebook    Twitter    Blog

More
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Disclaimer & Terms of Use
  • Local & Reviews
© The Babcock Law Firm. Colorado law firm for workers' compensation, car accidents & personal injury. Serving all of Colorado and the Denver metro area from our Denver law office law firm internet marketing by SEO Advantage®