• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Babcock-Tucker

Babcock Tucker

Denver personal injury and accident lawyer

  • Our Firm
    • Our Mission
    • Injury Attorney Profiles
    • Our Staff
    • How Representation Works
  • Practice Areas
    • Workers’ Compensation / Work Injuries
    • Car Accidents
    • Truck Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Drunk Driving Accidents
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Slip and Falls (Premises Liability)
    • Bad Faith Insurance
    • Wrongful Death
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Resources
    • COVID-19
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • (303) 683-5033
Denver Personal Injury Attorneys (Home) / Car Accidents / Common Arguments Used by Auto Accident Defendants

Common Arguments Used by Auto Accident Defendants

Looking for the right legal team to help you in an auto accident claim case?

Our Denver car accident attorneys have extensive experience handling injury cases. It doesn’t matter if you have a minor scrape or a major collision, we are here for you.

We’ll fight to recover the compensation you need to heal physically, emotionally, and financially.

Schedule your free consultation


If you’re at fault in a car accident, it’s not uncommon for any seriously injured persons to file a lawsuit against you for medical expenses and compensation for lost wages or pain and suffering. While this is not a comfortable place to find yourself, it’s important to know some common arguments (or defenses) used to dismiss a lawsuit and/or limit the extent of your liability (i.e. what you or your insurance has to pay).

Also, if you’re the one filing the lawsuit, you and your attorney need to be aware of these arguments in order to navigate your way through the legal process and avoid hitting a dead end.

Argument #1: “It wasn’t all my fault!”

In many cases, the defendant will claim that the accident was not his or her fault—or at least not solely his or her fault. We often see this in cases where both parties were in the wrong.

For example, one person might have been speeding at the time of the accident, and the other person might have been texting on their phone. In other cases, such as accidents that occur in parking lots, determining who has the right of way and who is at fault when an accident occurs may not always be clear.

Depending on what your state’s laws are, the argument that it wasn’t all your fault may or may not help. Some states are “no fault” states, which means each individual’s insurance pays for their own claims, regardless of who actually caused the accident.

Another handful of states have what’s called contributory negligence. In these 5 states, if a person is even 1% at fault for the accident, they are not eligible to receive any compensation for damages.

Most states follow either pure or modified comparative fault. This means that each person involved in an accident is assigned a percentage of the fault and compensated based on the rules set by that state. In many states, if you’re more than 50% or 51% at fault, you cannot receive compensation for damages. Colorado abides by a modified comparative fault rule in personal injury cases.

All that to say, if you are facing a car accident lawsuit and can prove that you were not entirely at fault for the accident, it could potentially get the lawsuit thrown out or at least lessen the amount you’re responsible to pay.

Argument #2: “The accident was years ago!”

Another common argument is that the lawsuit wasn’t filed during the statute of limitations, or the time period allotted by law for a lawsuit to be filed.

AllLaw.com describes it this way:

A statute of limitations defense is a matter of law, meaning that regardless of the facts surrounding the case, if the suit wasn’t filed in a timely manner, it will be time-barred. While there are some exceptions to statutes of limitations based on when a particular injury is discovered, the general rule is that if a case is filed too late, it won’t hold up in court.

If you have been sued for a Colorado car accident that occurred more than 3 years ago, time is on your side in this case. Very rarely are exceptions made for going beyond the statute of limitations.

Did you know?
Without a good lawyer, your cash settlement could be 6 to 7 times LESS than what you deserve.
Schedule your free consultation

Argument #3: “He wasn’t hurt THAT bad!”

The last argument that a defense will use is that the injured person is over exaggerating his or her injuries. Often, the plaintiff will claim they cannot do certain tasks that they can in fact do, or they won’t follow their doctor’s recommendations for recovery and injure themselves further. In either case, they are not providing accurate information about their injuries, and if they’re found out, their case can be severely weakened or even dismissed entirely.

Lawsuits are messy and building a good defense is crucial, so make sure to hire an experienced Colorado car crash lawyer that can guide you through the process. Mack Babcock has extensive legal experience and strives to help all of his clients receive a fair ruling in and out of court. Contact Babcock Tucker for a free consultation.

How Does Car Color Impact the Risk of Accidents?

Uncover the surprising link between car color and the likelihood of a crash.

Learn more

Footer

Client Testimonials

Highly Recommend
“I can highly recommend Babcock Tucker. They were very attentive, answered all of my questions and then took care of everything. I had nothing to worry about except getting better. The results were far better than I had expected. Thanks to them, I can now get on with my life.”
Jack
Great Team
“Babcock Tucker handled my case with great expertise. They were very informative and helpful. They are a team that really care about their clients and fight to make sure their clients are treated very fairly. I would highly recommend them to any one in need of a workers’ comp attorney.”
Leon
Outstanding Job
“Babcock Tucker did an outstanding job of representing me. I had never been involved in a work related injury case, so I had no idea what to expect. Mack and his staff did a great job of providing information and protecting my rights every step of the way…”
JC

Read All Reviews

As seen in:

Association Badges
Association Badges

Schedule your free consultation

(303) 683-5033
Babcock Tucker
Denver Workers' Compensation Lawyer and Personal Injury Attorney Mack Babcock
4600 S Ulster Street, Suite 800 Denver, CO 80237 United States

Statewide representation for Colorado's injured workers, including Aurora, Colorado Springs, Fort Collins and surrounding areas.

Personal Injury
Practice Areas

  • Car accidents
  • Truck accidents
  • Motorcycle accidents
  • Drunk driving accidents
  • Pedestrian accidents
  • Workers' comp / work injuries
  • Slip and falls (premises liability)
  • Insurance disputes
  • Wrongful death

Resources

  • Blog
  • Firm news
  • Scholarship

Free eBooks

  • Colorado workers' comp guide
  • Colorado car accident guide

Our Firm

  • Firm mission
  • Attorney profiles
  • Practice areas
  • Contact
More
  • Home
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Privacy policy
  • Disclaimer and terms
  • Reviews
Babcock Tucker: Colorado Enjuris Partner Attorney
    Facebook    Instagram    LinkedIn    TikTok    X/Twitter    Youtube    Blog
© 2025 Babcock Tucker. Colorado law firm for workers' compensation, car accidents & personal injury. Serving all of Colorado and the Denver metro area from our Denver law office.
Law firm Internet marketing by SEO Advantage®